Current:Home > MyDo your portfolio results differ from what the investment fund reports? This could be why. -NextGenWealth
Do your portfolio results differ from what the investment fund reports? This could be why.
Johnathan Walker View
Date:2025-04-10 01:39:32
You buy into a mutual fund or exchange-traded fund and expect to earn the same investment result. But invariably that doesn’t happen, and investors usually are the ones coming up short.
This lag in performance can be sizable, as researcher Morningstar discovered in its latest “Mind the Gap” study. If your stock fund earns 8% one year, for example, your own results might be closer to 6% or 7%.
How can you underperform the exact same fund that you own? Poor decisions explain a big part of it. Simply put, many people don’t just buy into a fund and then leave their money alone. Instead, they buy and sell along the way.
For the most part, "It boils down to the timing of purchases and sales into and out of funds," said Jeffrey Ptak, Morningstar's chief ratings officer.
In other words, poor timing decisions can easily chop one-fifth off of your return in a typical year.
Investors frequently buy or sell funds based on their reported total returns. These performance results for mutual and exchange-traded funds assume that a person has made a lump-sum investment on day one and held tight to the end, neither adding nor subtracting money. They also assume all dividends are reinvested, which might or might be the case for an investor in reality, and they assume management expenses and other costs have been deducted.
How much will I get after 10 years in mutual fund?
In Morningstar's latest study, investors earned about 6% annually over the 10 years ending Dec. 31, 2022. The funds themselves generated an annualized average gain of 7.7%, including reinvested dividends and subtracting costs.
The lag of 1.7 percentage points is similar to gaps of 1.5% to 1.7% that Morningstar calculated in four previous studies spanning earlier 10-year periods.
"In my opinion, this is one of the most important studies Morningstar publishes, because it shows that what you see isn't always what you get when it comes to fund returns," said Amy Arnott, a portfolio strategist with the company.
Timing mistakes, along with investment expenses and taxes, are among the critical factors that can influence a person’s end results. And unlike actual gyrations in the stock and bond markets, they are something over which investors exert at least some control. (Regarding taxes, there are ways to minimize the bite, and with expenses, it is easy to find low-cost products.)
Returns for investors almost always will differ from a fund's reported results unless a person makes no additions or subtractions during the entire holding period, Morningstar said. The more volatile a fund, the more difficult it typically is for investors to maintain a hands-off approach.
Responsible, disciplined strategies can lag, too
Sometimes, even sound approaches like investing on a regular basis can backfire, at least comparatively speaking.
Suppose you want to dollar-cost average by staking $1,000 into the same fund at the beginning of each year, for three years. Suppose, further, that the fund goes on to earn 10% the first year and 10% the second year before dropping 10% in year three. For the fund, that works out to an annualized return of 2.9%. But the investor sustains an overall loss of 0.4%. The reason?
“There was less money in the account during the first two years of positive returns and more money exposed to the loss during the third year,” Morningstar said.
A strategy of investing money on a regular basis, as when diverting a portion of your paycheck into a workplace 401(k) retirement account, is a laudable behavior, Ptak said. Still, it will give you a different end result compared with the fund in which you're placing money. So, too, with regular, ongoing withdrawals.
Investor returns rarely will match a fund’s results exactly, since few people can buy and hold for years. But the performance-gap study shows several ways to improve your results.
One is to avoid adding a lot of money after a fund has had a nice rally. Another is to avoid selling at a price that could be near the market bottom. In addition, investors should consider automating tasks like rebalancing as much as possible, perhaps by doing it on the same day each year. (Rebalancing involves adding a little money to lagging funds while taking some chips off the table with funds that have performed especially well, to keep your overall mix or allocation in line with your objective.)
More money:Americans are demanding more: Desired salary for new jobs now nearly $79,000
How to build wealth:These 5 things can make or break your ability to build wealth
Which type of fund is best?
Also, investors should consider sticking with more widely diversified funds and avoiding sector portfolios that hold fewer stocks, typically in one or a few industries like technology. These funds bounce around a lot more, making it harder to resist the urge to buy and sell. Conversely, more diversified funds such as asset-allocation portfolios, which typically spread their holdings among stocks, bonds, cash and perhaps other areas like real estate, deliver a smoother ride, making them more suitable for a long-term, buy-and-hold approach, Morningstar said.
In fact, investors suffered their lowest performance gap with asset allocation funds, among the categories that Morningstar studied, and the highest amount of lagging performance with sector portfolios.
Because of their smoother rides, asset-allocation and other widely diversified funds "do seem to be the easiest for investors to use," Ptak said.
Reach the writer at [email protected].
veryGood! (75481)
Related
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Everything you need to know about this year’s meeting of leaders at the UN General Assembly
- $6 billion in Iranian assets once frozen in South Korea now in Qatar, key for prisoner swap with US
- Underwater teams search for a helicopter that crashed while fighting a forest fire in western Turkey
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- UAW president Shawn Fain says 21% pay hike offered by Chrysler parent Stellantis is a no-go
- Mississippi officers justified in deadly shooting after police went to wrong house, jury rules
- Anderson Cooper on the rise and fall of the Astor fortune
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- Judge to hold hearing on ex-DOJ official’s request to move Georgia election case to federal court
Ranking
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- Military searches near South Carolina lakes for fighter jet whose pilot safely ejected
- Authorities identify 2 California pilots who died in air racing event in Reno, Nevada
- Authorities search for F-35 jet after 'mishap' near South Carolina base; pilot safely ejected
- Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
- Mega Millions jackpot reaches $162 million. See winning numbers for Sept. 15 drawing.
- Teyana Taylor and Iman Shumpert split after 7 years of marriage, deny infidelity rumors
- Broncos score wild Hail Mary TD but still come up short on failed 2-point conversion
Recommendation
Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
UAW strike day 4: GM threatens to send 2,000 workers home, Ford cuts 600 jobs
As leaders convene, the UN pushes toward its crucial global goals. But progress is lagging
South Florida debacle pushes Alabama out of top 25 of this week's NCAA 1-133 Re-Rank
Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
Trump reiterates request for Judge Tanya Chutkan to recuse herself from his D.C. Jan. 6 case
Military searching for F-35 fighter jet after mishap prompts pilot to eject over North Charleston, S.C.
NFL Week 2: Cowboys rout Aaron Rodgers-less Jets; Giants rally for comeback win